The tech startup sector is full of new ventures jostling for funding, and only a handful of them become successful. But at the more mature end of the tech sector, a few giant companies control the vast majority of online advertising. Google and Facebook have tremendous power to limit competition while they benefit from user data harvested from “free” use of their services, argues Chicago Booth’s Luigi Zingales, director of Booth’s Stigler Center for the Study of the Economy and the State. Zingales and Chicago Booth’s Raghuram G. Rajan, find that big tech firms stifle innovation when they buy up promising startups.
The Stigler Center’s Committee on Digital Platforms has studied the degree of market power digital platforms enjoy and the way this market power harms consumers. The tech giants have less incentive to innovate, maintain the quality of their services, or refrain from even more aggressive data-collection practices if their users don’t have alternative services to turn to. Limited competition in the market for online advertising could also drive up costs for advertisers, which could in turn result in higher prices for those companies’ customers. And as Zingales has argued, tech firms’ dominant position threatens to distort not only markets but the political system as well.
What can we do about it? One important step we could take, Zingales says, is to draw upon the regulatory playbook from the dawn of the telephone industry, in which networks were made to work together to allow their users to call each other. Such forced interoperability between digital platforms could help restore competition online.
Facebook is efficient. But so was Standard Oil, Luigi Zingales argues, in this excerpt from Chicago Booth Review's The Big Question video series.
Luigi Zingales: But you know, people say that data is the new oil. And Zuckerberg is the new Rockefeller. Now at the time of Rockefellerr, they used to say that he was more efficient. He was more efficient, but he controlled 95 percent of the refineries in the United States.
And he had deals that restricted the ability of shipping oil in a competitive way with the railways. So he was, effectively, abusing his market position, and I think that it was the right decision for the antitrust of the United States to go after Rockefeller and break up Standard Oil.
So if this was today, would you be in favor of breaking up Standard Oil, or not?
Discover these stories and much more at Chicago Booth Review.
Markets are becoming more concentrated and, arguably, less competitive.
Does America Have an Antitrust Problem?
The traditional economic model where high-priced buyouts helped drive innovation may no longer apply.
Why Big-Tech Mergers Stifle Innovation
The independent and nonpartisan committee studied in-depth how digital platforms such as Google and Facebook impact the economy and antitrust laws, data protection, the political system, and the news media industry.
Stigler Committee on Digital Platforms: Final ReportThrough their data-driven insights, our researchers are tackling some of the world's biggest global issues. Explore more research from Booth.
Booth researchers are exploring what should drive corporate decisions in the twenty-first century.
Should Companies Focus on Profits?
Booth researchers are exploring how discrimination gets embedded in algorithms—and how to address that.
Can Artificial Intelligence be Biased?
Booth researchers are investigating how cultural norms and expectations affect women’s progress.
Why Is the Glass Ceiling So Tough to Crack?The Chicago Approach to business education—Booth’s educational philosophy—will teach you how to turn any business challenge, no matter how small or large, into an opportunity. Learn how our transformative curriculum helps our students to ask better questions and discover better answers. No matter which MBA program you pursue—Full-Time, Part-Time, or Executive—you get the same transformative academic experience, the same world-class faculty, the same influential network, the same dynamic community.
Find out how our educational approach will prepare you to think for yourself, challenge the status quo, and ground discoveries in data.
Discover Academic Life at Booth
Our MBA curriculum gives you the skills to transcend trends and solve any business problem. Here’s how.
Master the Fundamentals of Business
The Full-Time MBA Program provides you with freedom: academic freedom, freedom to take risks, and freedom to define your impact in the world.
Full-Time MBA Program
Our top-ranked Evening MBA and Weekend MBA Programs accommodate the schedules and lifestyles of working, goal-oriented professionals.
Part-Time MBA Programs
To gain a global perspective, you need an MBA from a global school. Earn an MBA from Booth in Chicago, London, or Hong Kong without interrupting your career.
Executive MBA Program
Recruit the world’s top MBA students, support academic research, sponsor an event, and more. Our corporate partners have many opportunities to engage with Booth.
Recruit Chicago Booth Talent
Choose from nearly 50 open-enrollment programs worldwide, or create a custom program tailored to meet your organization’s unique challenges.
Executive Education
The Polsky Center bridges the gap between knowledge and practice, idea and action, and research and impact through education, partnerships, and new venture creation.
Polsky Center for Entrepreneurship and Innovation
The influence and impact of Chicago Booth faculty, students, and alumni extends throughout North America.
Booth in North America
Booth brings our MBA degree and Executive Education offerings and our own renowned faculty members to our new campus in London, the financial heart of Europe.
Learn More about Booth in Europe
Booth's Hong Kong campus brings our MBA degree and Executive Education offerings and our own renowned faculty members to this financial center of the Asia-Pacific region.
Building Connections in AsiaThe Executive MBA Program is registered under the Hong Kong Education Bureau. Registration No.: 262427. It is a matter of discretion for individual employers to recognise any qualification to which this course may lead.
Professor Mark Agnew, ’06, and Evening MBA student Cassy Horton are on a mission to help kids affected by a parent’s disease—and honor their late friend, Ned Smith, PhD ’10.
Finding New Purpose through TragedyBooth researchers are exploring how discrimination gets embedded in algorithms—and how to address that.
Can Artificial Intelligence be Biased?
Professor Linda Ginzel turned her in-demand classroom notes into a leadership workbook that is helping readers everywhere “develop their courage, capacity, and wisdom.”
Expanding the Definition of Leadership
