Next time you pick a movie to watch, consider one you’ve watched before. Research by Chicago Booth’s Ed O’Brien suggests that repeat experiences are more pleasurable than people expect them to be—and can be just as enjoyable, or more so, than entirely new experiences.
Past research has suggested that when it comes to leisure activities, people are intuitively drawn to new experiences. O’Brien’s research probed the subject further, finding that people also explicitly avoid repeating experiences—an aversion that he argues is due to a misperception of how little they’ll enjoy the repetition.
O’Brien conducted a series of seven experiments. In three of them, participants completed a leisure activity once—either visiting a museum exhibit, watching a movie, or playing a video game—and reported their enjoyment of it. Then some participants were asked to predict how much they’d enjoy repeating the same activity they’d just experienced, while others actually repeated the activities and reported their enjoyment. In some cases, enjoyment of the activity among those who actually experienced repetition declined somewhat, and in other cases it didn’t, but in every case, the predictors significantly overestimated how much repeating the activity would weigh on the enjoyment of it.
Study participants predicted that a second consecutive visit to a museum exhibit would be less enjoyable than the first, but those who actually repeated the experience enjoyed both visits equally.
The expectation that a repeated experience will be less enjoyable is so strong that people will make sacrifices to avoid it. In one study, which involved participants watching short virtual walking tours of cities, some viewers were asked after the first tour whether they wanted to rewatch that city’s tour or watch a tour of a new city. Ninety-two percent of the sample opted for a new city—and most were willing to give up, on average, 12 percent of their study-participation payment to avoid rewatching a tour.
Granted, the offer to trade earnings for novelty carries the underlying implication that repetition is undesirable and could have pushed some participants to pay up to avoid a dull experience. But if that were true, the offer would have prompted the few people who opted to rewatch the tour to change their minds—and it didn’t.
So why are repeated experiences more enjoyable than we expect? Two of O’Brien’s experiments suggest it’s because they’re not repeated exactly: each time you rewatch a movie, revisit a museum, or reread a book, you discover new aspects of it that make the experience at least partially novel. In contrast, when you imagine repeating an experience, your mind simply replays the same old experience again and again.
Feelings of envy may be more potent for future events than for past ones.
Time May Be the Best Treatment for Jealousy
Giving to others might make you happier in the long run and has staying power, whereas the joy of receiving fades quickly.
Want to Be Happier? Give More to OthersThe results are relevant beyond one’s choice of leisure activities. O’Brien points out that students may skip a class because they have already heard a particular lecture or learned a concept, and by skipping it, they miss the opportunity of continued learning that their attendance might promote.
“These findings . . . remind us that the past may sometimes feel just as ‘new,’ and as enjoyable, as the future—at least, not as dull as it plays out in one’s mind,” O’Brien writes. “Repetition too could add an unforeseen spice to life.”
Ed O’Brien, “Enjoy It Again: Repeat Experiences Are Less Repetitive than People Think,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, April 2019.
Chicago Booth behavioral science professor George Wu discusses the art of constructive criticism.
How Should You Deliver Negative Feedback?
How can you make 2024 that exceptional year when you actually keep your New Year’s resolutions? In this episode, we get advice from Chicago Booth’s Ayelet Fishbach.
How to Keep Your New Year’s Resolutions
Small factors make a big difference for medical decisions.
Line of Inquiry: Devin G. Pope on How a Cold Day Can Make Doctors Prescribe More Medicine
The technological landscape has changed rapidly for investors.
Example Article Swiss
The language of earnings calls can help diagnose economic outcomes associated with periods of uncertainty.
Example Article Swiss
Stabilizing their currencies relative to the dollar offers benefits to smaller economies.
Example Article Swiss
Immigrants bring with them increased likelihood of foreign direct investment from their native countries.
Example Article Swiss
Refugees may be the secret to long-term economic growth.
Example Article Swiss
Despite the assertions of the Leave campaign, immigration can be economically beneficial, especially in the long run.
Example Article Swiss
There's a long-term economic argument for welcoming immigrants: they attract foreign investment.
Example Article Swiss
Strasbourg, France, is a picturesque city on the Rhine river—with a dark stain on its history.
Example Article Swiss
When protesters took to Cairo’s Tahrir Square in 2011 to oppose a decades-old Egyptian regime, it wasn’t just a powerful political statement—it also upended the cozy relationship between the government and favored companies.
Example Article SwissYour Privacy
We want to demonstrate our commitment to your privacy. Please review Chicago Booth's privacy notice, which provides information explaining how and why we collect particular information when you visit our website.