If a person is trying to quit smoking, she might seek out advice from someone who has successfully quit. But research by University of Pennsylvania’s Lauren Eskreis-Winkler and Angela Duckworth and Chicago Booth’s Ayelet Fishbach suggests a counterintuitive strategy: she should try giving advice to someone also struggling to quit.
“Our research provides empirical support for an age-old aphorism: it is in giving that we receive,” the researchers write.
Conventional wisdom holds that receiving advice is an effective motivator, but research has been picking away at this idea, finding, for example, that receiving advice can make people feel less confident. Eskreis-Winkler, Fishbach, and Duckworth further studied the link between advice and motivation—and argue that it can be more motivating to give advice than to receive it.
In their first experiment, the researchers had some middle-school students give advice about vocabulary coursework and had others receive advice about it from their teachers. They then tracked how many minutes the middle schoolers spent studying vocabulary online each night, using minutes spent studying as a measure of motivation. It turns out that the students who gave advice studied almost 27 minutes on average while those receiving it put in closer to 23 minutes.
People are more willing to invest in a goal itself than the means to that goal, even if it leads them to overinvest.
Want to Motivate People? Stress Goals, Not Means
Uncertainty can often inspire anxiety. It has been shown to have negative effects on the markets and even the economy at large.
Uncertainty Can Improve MotivationNext, the team conducted a study with adults who were struggling to save money, lose weight, control their temper, or find employment. Participants wrote out the advice they’d give to others, and then received advice themselves. Afterward, they rated which felt more motivational, giving advice or receiving it.
Almost three-quarters of the participants across all four categories reported that giving advice was more motivating than receiving it. This was true regardless of whether they received advice first and gave it second, or vice versa.
People often underestimate—or completely miss—the role that confidence plays in motivation, according to the research. When participants rated their confidence in giving and receiving advice, they consistently reported that giving advice made them feel more confident and motivated.
Lauren Eskreis-Winkler, Ayelet Fishbach, and Angela Duckworth, “Dear Abby: Should I Give Advice or Receive It?,” Psychological Science, in press.
Chicago Booth behavioral science professor George Wu discusses the art of constructive criticism.
How Should You Deliver Negative Feedback?
Survey evidence affirms a clear cultural divide between East and West.
Infographic: A Better Measure of Collectivism
Small factors make a big difference for medical decisions.
Line of Inquiry: Devin G. Pope on How a Cold Day Can Make Doctors Prescribe More MedicineYour Privacy
We want to demonstrate our commitment to your privacy. Please review Chicago Booth's privacy notice, which provides information explaining how and why we collect particular information when you visit our website.